Happy Pie Day: What Utensil Is Best to Eat Pie With?
Few desserts bring as much joy as a freshly baked pie. Whether it’s a warm slice of apple pie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or a decadent slice of chocolate cream pie from Costco, using the right utensil can enhance your pie-eating experience. But have you ever wondered—what is the best utensil to eat pie with?
The answer depends on the type of pie, its texture, and how you like to enjoy it. Let’s break it down!
The Fork: A Classic Choice
When in doubt, reach for a fork! A standard dessert fork is the most common utensil for eating pie, and for good reason.
✅ Best for:
-
Traditional fruit pies (apple, cherry, blueberry)
-
Custard pies (pumpkin, pecan, sweet potato)
-
Crumb-topped pies
Why it works:
-
The fork tines easily cut through the flaky pie crust.
-
The slight curve allows you to scoop up both filling and crust in one perfect bite.
-
It provides just enough control for pies that hold their shape but have a soft, scoopable filling.
Pro Tip: For pies with a firm and buttery crust use the side of the fork to gently press down and break through without crushing the filling.
The Spoon: The Creamy Pie Essential
A spoon might not be the first utensil you think of for pie, but, believe it or not,it’s actually the best option for certain varieties!
✅ Best for:
-
Cream pies (banana cream, coconut cream, chocolate silk)
-
Meringue-topped pies (lemon meringue, key lime)
-
Ice cream-topped or warm pies with melted filling
Why it works:
-
The round bowl of a spoon helps scoop soft, creamy fillings without making a mess.
-
It’s ideal for pies served with whipped cream or a melting ice cream scoop.
-
You won’t lose any of that delicious, smooth filling between fork tines.
Pro Tip: If your pie is extra soft or gooey, a dessert spoon will ensure you get every bite without the hassle of trying to cut through it with a fork.
The Knife and Fork Combo: For Extra Precision
Sometimes, a fork alone just won’t cut it—literally. That’s when a knife comes in handy!
✅ Best for:
-
Dense or firm-crust pies (thick pecan pie, deep-dish pies)
-
Frozen or chilled pies that are tough to cut through
-
Pies with thick crusts that don’t break easily with a fork
Why it works:
-
A butter knife lets you gently cut through thick crust without smashing the filling.
-
This method helps keep your slice looking neat and intact.
Pro Tip: When dining at a formal setting, you may be served pie with both a fork and a knife—use the knife to cut bites and the fork to lift them to your mouth.
Hands: The Ultimate Casual Pie Experience
Some pies were made to be eaten by hand, and there’s no shame in enjoying them that way!
✅ Best for:
-
Hand pies (apple turnovers, mini pies)
-
Crumbly, graham cracker-crust pies (some cheesecakes, key lime pie bars)
-
Picnic or on-the-go snacking
Why it works:
-
No utensils required—just grab and bite!
-
Ideal for pies with a sturdy crust that holds its shape.
Pro Tip: If you’re eating a softer pie by hand, use a napkin or parchment paper to avoid sticky fingers.
Final Verdict: What’s the Best Utensil for Pie?
Ultimately, the best utensil for eating pie depends on the type of pie and how you like to enjoy it.
🥧 Fork: The all-purpose pie utensil—great for most pies.
🥄 Spoon: Best for creamy, soft, or ice cream-topped pies.
🍴 Knife & Fork: Perfect for firm or thick-crusted pies.
🍽️ Spork: A fun, practical choice for mixed-texture pies.
🙌 Hands: Ideal for hand pies and on-the-go snacking.
No matter how you slice (or scoop!) pie is always delicious. Just grab the utensil that works best for you, and enjoy every last bite!
How do you enjoy your pie?
